Home  Tests  Types  Diagrams  Books  Forums  Goals  Search
Main | Type 4 | Type 5 | Movie | Care | Chat

Enneagram Chat Board Archive

Strange how one could accept scientific knowledge such as this and yet still be a t heist.
[ Boards: Main, Type4, Movie, Care, Chat ][ Top 10 ] [ HOME ]

Strange how one could accept scientific knowledge such as this and yet still be a t heist.


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Enneagram Chat Board ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Jayne nt on September 07, 2001 at 01:19:53:

In Reply to: Wormholes posted by P on September 06, 2001 at 09:01:34:

: A powerful new X-ray telescope has yielded evidence that virtually
: clinches the case for the existence of a supermassive black hole at the
: center of our galaxy, astronomers say.

: Scientists generally hold that almost every galaxy revolves around a
: black hole. Previous studies have estimated that the center of our
: galaxy, the Milky Way, contains something very dense and massive,
: which most scientists already believed was a black hole.

: ****When speaking of black holes, and worm holes (not referring to Isaacs urethra!) refer to the treatise below:

: Introduction

: In many science fiction books and films one often find the story of people travelling backward
: or forward in time. How many haven't seen the film "Back to the Future", where Michael J.
: Fox travels back in time to where his mother and father where young and then his mother falls
: in love with him instead of his father and therefore he ceases to exist. That is science fiction
: but what is really allowed if one take into account the Law of Physics? Is it possible to travel
: in time and is it possible to change the past and therefore also change the present? We should
: here try to give a short description of what physicist know about time travels today. To be
: able to talk about time travels we will first have to explain what a wormhole is.

: Description of a wormhole

: A wormhole is a geometry of four-dimensional spacetime (for an explanation of spacetime see
: "spacetime" and "spacetime diagrams") in which two regions of the universe are connected by
: a short narrow throat. A classical large scale wormhole is a solution of the Einstein's field
: equations, which governs the curvature of spacetime. The most interesting thing with
: wormholes is that they could provide relatively easy means of travelling to distant regions of
: space or even of travelling backwards in time.


: Figure 1. A wormhole with two mouths making a shortcut in spacetime.

: The problem is that a macroscopic wormhole is not a static structure, itīs rather a shape that
: expands from a singularity with zero throat radius to maximum radius and then shrinks back
: to a singularity again. This expansion-reduction of the radius would be very quick. Even light
: would not have a chance to pass through the wormhole before it shrinks back to zero radius
: again. In fact any now known matter that would fall into the wormhole would pull it together
: through gravity. If constructing a mathematical model of an open wormhole that allows
: passage, the equations of general relativity says that matter with an enormous negative
: pressure is needed to uphold the wormhole gravitationally. The magnitude of the tension of
: the matter must be greater than the energy density of the matter itself. This would leave us
: with a material that will have a negative energy density relative to a light beam travelling
: through it. This kind of material is called exotic matter because there is no such matter now
: known. There are some indications that exotic matter can exist. For example between two
: metal plates there can be field fluctuations that has a negative energy density relative to the
: field fluctuations in free vacuum. Evaporating black holes also implies that exotic matter can
: exist.

: Another problem with wormholes is that fields can destroy them. Fields are in some solutions
: able to increase its strength for each passage through a wormhole. If the wormhole has a
: focusing effect, the total field strength becomes infinite and will therefore destroy the
: wormhole. If the hole is defocusing, it converges towards a finite value and the wormhole can
: survive. The only matter that can make the wormhole defocusing is exotic matter. If exotic
: matter exists and has the ability to uphold a wormhole without interacting with and harming
: the traveller, then there is a physical possibility of a traversable wormhole and for it to even
: work as a time machine. A wormhole can be turned into a time machine by keeping one
: mouth of the wormhole fixed while moving the other. This can be made through gravitational
: attraction or by charging it electrically while moving it with electric fields. Travelling from the
: stationary mouth to the moving and back again could then send a traveller back in time.

: How time travel is possible, "the Twin Paradox"

: It is easy to see how one can make a time machine if one consider the "twin paradox" in
: special relativity (for an explanation of this paradox see "Explanation of the twin paradox").
: Let an observer A be fixed in a frame and let B be another observer moving with (high)
: velocity u relative to A. The clock moving with B is then going with a slower rate than a A's
: clock because of the time dilation in special relativity. One can write an expression that relate
: both time as: T=gamma*T' where gamma is the Lorentz factor:

:

: Since gamma is always > 1 B's clock is going slower than A's. To have a time machine A and
: B must be able to hold on to one of the wormholes mouths each. A and B can then
: communicate either through space or through the wormhole. A message sent through space
: travels with the speed of light while a message sent through the wormhole takes a shortcut in
: spacetime. A message sent through the wormhole will therefore arrive almost at once if the
: wormhole is short. In figure 2 one can see a spacetime diagram of the situation.


: Figure 2. Spacetime diagram of a possible time machine.

: In the figure one can see how B's clock goes slower than A's. If A sends a message to B at t =
: 0 through space and B replies through the wormhole the message will return to A at a time t
: larger than zero. But because time dilation add up while B is moving relative to A there will
: after a while be a time when the A observer receives the message at the same time he sends it.
: This is the so called "time travel boundary". After that time closed time-like curves are formed
: and A receives his message before he sends it. This implies that time travel is possible, but of
: course you have to find a macroscopic, stable wormhole to be able to travel through it and
: you must also be able to control its mouth. One sees in the spacetime diagram that it isn't
: possible to go back to times before the time travel boundary was formed. This is a severe
: limitation of such time travels.

: The Principle of Self-Consistent Solutions, "the Grandparent
: Paradox".

: One of the problem with time travel is the so called "grandparent" paradox. Suppose you are
: moving backwards in time and kill your grandparent before he or she has any children. Could
: you do this and not, in doing so, eliminating your own existence? And even if you do that,
: then no one killed your grandparent in the first place and your birth is possible again! You
: could form a postulate that states that these events are forbidden, but that would in a sense
: mean that you have no free will since you are not "allowed" to kill your grandparent then. The
: essence of this problem is pinpointed in the billiard ball analogy. Suppose you have a billiard
: table with two holes. These holes are connected by a wormhole.


: Figure 3. Self-consistent and not self-consistent solutions to the billiard ball problem

: If you shoot a billiard ball towards and into a wormhole and it is shot out of the other mouth,
: but at an earlier time (due to hole's time travel effect) and then collides with the billiard ball
: before it reaches the first hole, it would change its direction so much that it doesn't reach the
: hole in the first place. Is such a solution allowed? If it is we have a real paradox. This is
: illustrated in figure 3A. If you change the initial conditions slightly you often receive an infinite
: number of solutions but not all of them are self-consistent. Self-consistency means that an
: event is not allowed to change the past and that the future already has affected the past! This
: means that we are able to neglect all the solutions when the first ball misses the hole due to
: the collision with the second. The solutions listed below and in figure 3A-F above and they all
: use Newtonian mechanics everywhere except in the wormhole that is linking the two mouths.

: I will from now on call the ball that we have in our hand before we begins as the "first" ball
: and call the time-travelled version for the "second". If the second ball hits the first ball at just
: a slightly different angle and only giving it a glancing blow so that the first still will fall into the
: hole, but at a different angle than it had "before", then the solution will be self-consistent
: (figure 3 B). In the figure there are demonstrated a number of different solution classes. The
: figure D is one of the most interesting. There the first's vector is missing the hole altogether,
: but the second ball appears from one of the holes and collides with the first, and by doing so
: forces the first into the hole and thereby enables it to collide with "itself". This is quite similar
: to the fluctuations of quantum mechanics and the probability for such an event has a certain
: value, and are therefore not necessarily forbidden. The most common solutions are the ones
: in figure 3 E and F.

: All these different solutions are just different approaches to the "true" grandparent paradox.
: But this is not really a paradox, as it first seems. It seems that the past is already set, but so is
: the future! But this limits the free will of a person, since he is not allowed to kill his
: grandparent due to the laws of causality (for an explanation of causality see "causality"). But
: these restrictions of free will are a common part of our daily life. Even if you want to walk on
: the wall, gravity prevents the efforts to do so. So it is no paradox and the rules of physics are
: preserved. This gives us reason to believe that time travel may be physically more possible
: than we perhaps may think, although there are a lot more to learn in the subject.

: Conclusions

: We have seen that time travels, in the way that is given above, doesn't violate the law of
: physics, although it seems that we cannot realise it in the nearby future. We are in fact not
: even sure that exotic matter exists and if it exists it isn't very probable that we can collect
: enough of it to feed a wormhole. We also have to find a macroscopic wormhole to feed with
: this exotic matter. The problems are many and if it really is possible it will take many years
: before we overcome them. Physicists don't agree if time travel is possible. Stephen Hawking
: wrote in 1993: "... the best evidence we have that time travel is not possible, and will never
: be, is that we have not been invaded by hordes of tourists from the future". Time travels
: might be allowed theoretically but real ones are still science fiction.




Follow Ups:



Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:

Comments:

Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Enneagram Chat Board ] [ FAQ ]
chatboard/messages/11216.html